Thursday, 25 April 2013

The Case for an Indonesian Downhill Ski Team

I’m going to start working on a proposal to develop a national Indonesian downhill ski team, for several great reasons. First of all, balance - they’ve got it, as a result of riding motorbikes - from birth as passengers & then as soon as they’re big enough to reach the controls on their own (the licensing age is 14, but rules aren’t always followed). Many women ride pillion sidesaddle, which demands its own delicate balance & women drivers in (very) high heels are everywhere. Families of four or five will fit with relative comfort onto a bike. And I’ve seen everything from dozens of eggs to 10 foot ladders and full size bookcases loaded onto tiny scooters. Got to get from A to B somehow, right?

An "intersection" - guy with his arm out & a whistle guiding van into the stream of traffic across about 5 and a half lanes of oncoming vehicles.
Second reason - control. Driving on a bike in Indonesian traffic is exactly like negotiating the closest bunny hill to Toronto the day after Christmas on downhill skis. First rule - don’t worry about what’s behind you - you have no control over the guy coming up on your right or the minibus trying to pass you on your left, you need to keep your eyes on the next pothole in front of you & your rearview mirrors really only give you a glimpse of half of your own arm & a somewhat terrifying snapshot of the masses of scooters in the rear. So the strategy to safely & calmly driving around Makassar is just what you’d do on a black diamond slope with occasional moguls - weave around those slower than you, leave room for unexpected co-recreationalists popping out from the trees or side trails, and be ready to stop when the newbie in front crosses his tips - at the same time scanning the surface for holes, bumps and slippery patches. After you’ve got all that down, it’s quite fun. But it does demand a lot of focus, & you need regular breaks to slow your heart down.

And the third reason that I can see gold for downhill skiing in Indonesia’s future - optimism. It may be because I’m still working on the language but I haven’t met a cynical Indonesian (yet). In fact, the country faces many of the same difficulties we do in North America - although currently they have better economic growth, unemployment and underemployment is high, there are very limited opportunities for young people & even those with university degrees earn very low wages. But the Indonesians I know look forward with a (somewhat confusing to me) belief that their lives are getting better. They commonly express ambitious goals & sincerely believe that these are within reach.

To some extent, I think that this cheerful attitude towards life can be explained by the bahasa Indonesia word ‘belum’. Essentially, it means ‘not yet’. If someone asks you ‘have you had lunch?’ the answer wouldn’t be ‘no’, it would be ‘belum’. This could be interpreted as: not yet, I’d love to, the possibility is still out there, what have you got? You get the same answer if you ask someone on this island whether they’ve been to Bali. Belum - but the universe may get me there sooner or later. Most Indonesians can’t afford the plane ticket to travel off their own island, and hotels are completely out of reach. But, whether the question is ‘have you finished your homework’ or ‘are you married’ or ‘have you taken that commercial flight to the moon’, you’d hear ‘belum’. But ‘belum’ says it all. The possibility is always out there. That one word might just reflect a uniquely Indonesian deep-seated optimism. I can learn from that. 

I haven’t started my ski team proposal, belum.

Thursday, 28 March 2013

Getting what you need - Shopping


Open air markets are the shopping centres for fresh local food, clothes, kitchen utensils & many other goods. Every village of any size hosts a market weekly or bi-weekly; our local market runs twice a week from about 7 to 10 am. Indonesian families may be more likely to own a television than a refrigerator, which seemed quite strange to me at first. But after a trip to the market, things are a little clearer. When you can grow food all year around, long-term food storage is less of a priority. Rice is dried of course, so even in areas where only one crop a year can be grown, it’s easily stored. Fruit comes into season at different times of the year, so while you can’t find mangos now (December & January is harvest time for these), rambutan & durian are available. Papayas are still growing & will be ready to eat in a month or two. Market vegetables (tomatoes, potatoes, beans, water spinach & others) are grown pretty much continuously. 

So, why would you need a fridge? The ice cream guy drives by on his motorbike with a cooler mounted on the rear seat at least once a day. The other strange (to me) thing, ‘though is that fresh dairy products are non-existent in smaller towns & villages. Milk is sold in powdered or canned version. I say “strange” because there seems to be no shortage of cows & goats resident in these areas. I assume they are raised for their meat & the milk is taken to be processed. Processed "cheese" food, regular milk & margarine are available in larger towns, but only one (pricey) store in Makassar that caters mostly to expats stocks yoghurt, cheese & butter. Let me tell you: you quickly realize how heavily a North American diet leans on dairy food when you can’t get any.

The local lawn service providing mowing & fertilizing, but not milk.
Aside from Indonesians who make their living farming or fishing, there are probably millions of independent businesses run by individuals & families here. Most common are small shops (toko) & diners (warung) which can be found in even the tiniest settlements. The shops sell a variety of necessities - soap, candy, batteries, coffee, bread, & all sorts of processed goods (cookies, ramen noodles, etc). 

Indonesians talk about food the same way Canadians talk about the weather, even ‘though it’s not terribly interesting & much less variable than spring in New Brunswick. Warungs may specialize in seafood, chicken or meat (with rice or noodles), but even though they’re all independently owned the menus are predictable and seem to be designed by one big central franchiser. 

Other small businesses seem to be ruled by extreme specialization; roadside stalls will have fish or vegetables or fruit & very rarely more than one type of item. This tendency persists in many shops in larger cities selling manufactured goods. A while back a couple of us went looking for motorbike gloves & quickly learned that a store selling helmets does not sell gloves, or anything else you might need for your bike.

Almost everyone uses cell phones (landlines can only be found in offices), and stalls selling pulsa (time for your phone) are common as well. And cheap - approximately $1.20 Cdn for enough time to give you about 3 weeks of texting & talking.

So, let’s get down to prices - what does it cost to live here? My volunteer allowance is roughly $8.00 Cdn per day, which is well more than adequate to buy food, drinking water, phone time, gas, & some extras. Housing is provided under our agreements, & although some volunteers have to buy electricity, I don’t. In fact, my allowance is luxurious compared to my work partner, who earns slightly more than half of what I do. Rent for a modest house may run between $700 to $800 Cdn a year, but even quite a large house won’t be much more than $1200 Cdn annually. Gas, about $0.25 per litre, water, $1.30 for a large dispenser container. Indonesians are amazed when I tell them what I earned at my last Canadian job - but I’m careful to qualify the amount by also telling them our prices, including the cost of heat in winter.

In Denpasar (& Jakarta, I assume, although I haven’t been there yet) you can find pretty much any consumer good you need from computers to yoghurt. Fewer “western” goods can be found in Makassar, but many large malls are springing up there with department stores, bakeries, electronic shops, hardware & of course, Starbucks, McDonalds, Pizza Hut & KFC. Dunkin’ Donuts has gotten in on the ground floor here, & Indonesians (like most everyone else) love donuts - there’s an opportunity here for Tim Horton’s. 

Saturday, 16 March 2013

New job, new house


Didn’t really expect to be wearing socks to bed for warmth while living in Indonesia, but my new home is a bit chilly & it has been raining quite a lot over the last 3 weeks. I invested in a fleece blanket, am glad I packed jeans & several long-sleeved shirts & it’s a nice change not to be continuously sweating while simply sitting on the couch. 

Amir collecting samples
I’m living in the left half of the house (photo on left). Cristine, a graduate student from Italy who is studying macaques; their behaviour, eating preferences, and nutrition; shares the other half with her assistant, Amir, who is multi-talented and indispensable. He climbs 40-metre trees to gather samples, cooks dinners, fixes electrical cords, cleans fish, does motorcycle maintenance etc. etc. Cristine has been here for almost 3 years, so we communicate in bahasa Indonesia - me not having much Italian (that is, none). I’m sure I’m now picking up the accent with my bahasa ‘though, so it’ll be a strange variant that I’m speaking. I went out to the forest with them a couple of weeks ago & saw one large monkey travelling through. There are 3 bands in the local area - 2 resident in UnHas forest and one in Bantimurang National Forest, the boundaries of which abut the Learning Forest. 

The picture to the left is my side yard - a wide rice field surrounded by the limestone hills. The higher elevations have pine forests and lower down the slopes are covered with mixed species dipterocarp forest. The karst geology leaves a landscape with steep-sided hills, frequent landslides in the rainy season & river valleys that vary from narrow to wide plains. I saw an article in the news that karst is also subject to sinkholes - one of these swallowed a man in Florida a couple of weeks ago. That’s not one of my major concerns. It’s a beautiful landscape & a relatively quiet location. The road is about 100 metres downhill, so there’s some traffic noise, constant hum of insects and a weird snuffling noise outside my house last week (I didn’t get up to check - sounded like a wild pig, which is possible). I’ve started seeds for a garden - lettuce, tomatoes, beans, zucchini & herbs - and am looking forward to fresh produce in a few months. The local market is convenient (2 days a week), but I’m pretty sure I can grow equivalent or better veggies right outside my front door.
Tree roots on rock
Local scenery













The job? Well, it has some potential. My work partner Nasri & I have several projects that will make the Learning Forest a more valuable and organized resource for research, education and local outreach that are priorities for the university. We’re developing a short after-school environmental programme, need to start work on a waste management plan for the main site, and delineate boundaries of the agroforestry model area as a first step in establishing that as a learning tool. I’m being very generous with our timeline - in six months we may see a few baby step results.



About once a week or so I should be able to get into the city, Makassar (when the cats aren't using my bike) to work at the university office & eventually teach a couple of subjects. Not to mention, get a caffeine fix at Starbucks & pick up some groceries. Next week is already looking busy - a quick trip to Singapore for visa renewal, then a two-day session given by Mangrove Action Project to learn about rehabilitation of degraded coastline habitat. More on this later.

Friday, 1 March 2013

Adapting to change - again

True to form, I’ve changed jobs after only 3 months with the forestry office in Jeneponto. Not my fault, I swear. One of the things I’ve learned about development work, from my placement and through talking to other volunteers, is that the work partner’s perception of appropriate employment for a volunteer often conflicts with CUSO & VSO clear understanding of our role. We’re employed to build capacity & share our skills with the work partner and employees of the organizations in which we’re placed. Unfortunately, many volunteers are frequently expected to just do the work themselves or, as in my case with the forestry office, to simply be present & add “prestige” to the office simply by being the “pet” foreigner. The outcome was that I was assigned no tasks, no people to train & no resources with which to train them. Imagine my confusion when one of the reasons my work partner stated for wanting a volunteer was to train employees to use the GIS system for mapping & I arrive at the office to find that there are no computers. None. Tough to accomplish the goal. The forestry office simply had no practical use for or plan of how to employ a volunteer, but had applied anyway, and been assigned one (me). VSO staff have told us that often organizations in countries that are international aid recipients will simply apply for anything & everything - money, resources or people - and see what they get. And a volunteer is not the grand prize, with the requirement to house us & ease our adaptation to a different culture & language. I’m sure most work partners are thinking “just send cash”, particularly when they realize that we have an expectation of meaningful employment, which means that they should have some kind of long-term strategy for development of their activity areas. We often feel more like the booby prize - especially after our morning bath with a bucket of cold water.

It’s actually rather a grim commentary on awareness & planning by international aid programs, and the overall effectiveness of volunteers.  Work partners that have no plan, recognition of value of the resource, or ability to effectively employ volunteers are frequently failing to take advantage of the valuable knowledge & skills sitting at an empty desk in their offices. Often, the result is that volunteers leave placements early with a sense of having failed to accomplish even the most basic goals in passing on skills that are patently lacking in their work partner’s organizations. And probably go home with a jaded view of international aid itself. 

Luckily (I think) an alternate placement in Indonesia was available, and I’ve moved to the province of Maros (still in South Sulawesi) to a small community called Bengo. It’s in an area of karst ecology, limestone hills & thick forests. I’m living in the Learning Forest owned and operated by the Forestry Faculty of the University Hasanuddin (UnHas), which is in Makassar, 2 hours southwest of here. My job will be to assist the forest manager in creating a long-term plan for use of the forest, and perhaps in a few months teach a couple of courses at UnHas. That makes my inner bahasa-Indonesian-speaking self quail a bit, but it’s certainly motivation to improve my language skills.  

So, will my employment in this placement fit the volunteer role of sharing skills & capacity-building? Maybe. When I say “it’s not just me”, I know - because almost every other volunteer I’ve talked to in this country and in a couple of others have run up against the same brick wall. Another example: An application from an organization states that they need a volunteer to train local staff on how to create video training materials. But they find it’s easier just to have the volunteer videographer film the material themselves, rather than motivate local staff to learn the skill. Then the volunteer leaves after a year, and the organization applies for the next one, failing to realize, or not caring, that the opportunity to have the knowledge in-house & on an ongoing-basis has been lost, again. It’s a problem. It needs to be addressed. How is a question for aid experts to answer, but the first step is recognition. Otherwise, we’re all wasting our time.

Wednesday, 30 January 2013

The Package Tour Experience

The parents, having fun &
 making sure I'm still alive.

Last week, my mom & stepdad visited. Well, they stopped in Bali for 3 days as the beginning to a 3-week Southeast Asia cruise, but it was really just for my mom to check up on me. So I took a few vacation days & met them at their resort in Nusa Dua, on the southeastern coast at the southern end of the island. While I could have sat on the lovely clean beach for the whole three days, my mom has different ideas & signed us up for a bus tour for the whole of Wednesday, and a late afternoon tour on Thursday. I did get to beach-sit on Thursday morning. The experience violently reminded me of why I avoid the package vacation (well that, & I can't afford them). The typical Balinese tour is particularly reminiscent of being squeezed through a sausage factory: many buses lined up at one stop, buffet meals at barn-size restaurants & about 5 hours on a bus per hour of sightseeing. We attended two kecak dances, both venues packed to overcapacity such that the dancers had to move members of the audience in between acts to allow them room to exit & enter the floor. One volcano, invisible due to clouds & rain (well, it is the off-season, since it is the rainy season), two temples - at one of these locations we were given half an hour to race down 315 steps & then race back up to the bus. And remember, the average age on these tours is probably between 70 & 75 - hale & hearty North Americans & Europeans, but still I had an urge to pack a portable defibrillator. (Honesty time: I skipped the steps & bargained for sarongs with some of the stall owners on the roadside instead). 


Kecak dancer at Uluwattu.
Excited tourists at Uluwattu. The sarongs must be
worn on temple grounds, and are lent out at the entrance.





All in all, the tours were unpleasant reminders of the rapid & unchecked expansion of the tourist industry in Bali. From my parent’s hotel you can see two other huge hotels under construction in addition to the newly opened 1000-room resort in the other direction. The beach is not privately owned by the resorts, but public access is discouraged - roads down to the beach are obscure & unsigned. The surfers know where to go. Throughout the Balinese southern peninsula and up the western coast of Kuta and Selinyak hotels are springing up like mushrooms in a damp lawn. I cringed when I accessed my mom’s resort on the internet describing the beach located “on a reclaimed mangrove forest”. No, guys, if it was reclaimed there would be mangroves there. (There aren’t.)

Another hotel under construction & a cleared section of cliff for the next one.
I certainly don’t begrudge Indonesians chances at better jobs & higher pay, which these resorts and tourist attractions bring. However, the island infrastructure is obviously not able to keep pace with private development. Concerns have been expressed by politicians about the strain placed on roads and water supply, but the government would have to move very quickly or place a moratorium on further construction immediately to attempt to deal with the issues, and there is little sign that this will happen in the near future. The Denpasar airport is currently being upgraded & enlarged primarily to accommodate more tourism, and a four-lane bypass from the airport directly to Nusa Dua is being built in the bay. And we can’t blame foreigners for all this - the unique Hindu character of Bali attracts millions of Indonesian tourists every year as well.

Luckily, Indonesia is a country of 17,000 islands, of which Bali is only one. There are far more beautiful beaches, mountains & forests on other islands (but I’m not telling where, just in case an hotelier is reading this). So hopefully, concerned Indonesians, of which there are many, will be able to preserve the natural beauty of miles & miles of coastline & acres of native forest before they're “discovered”, and site reasonably sized, eco-hotels away from the more fragile areas. And offer walking or small boat tours of mangrove forests. The temples & other historical sites - well, they’re a write-off for contemplative, quiet consideration. Worth seeing, yes, but sharpen your elbows & resign yourself to standing in long lines to see the architecture.  

After seeing the parents off to the rest of their vacation, I headed back “home” where today my friend Rita took me to 2 beaches outside of town on jalan-jalan*. We ran into 2 other people & listened to the waves.

*jalan-jalan = a trip, usually just for fun, to kill time

Thursday, 3 January 2013

Selamat Tahun Baru! (Happy New Year)


Some random notes:

The rainy season has started in earnest; at times torrential for the last 3 days. My work partner tells me we can expect almost daily rain in January tapering off through February & March. Therefore, it’s rice planting season, & I’ve seen a lot of that activity. Mostly manual labour, the fields are first tilled with a kind of large rototiller pushed either manually or with a small engine attached, and the rest is all man- or woman- or kid-powered - hand planting rice plant seedlings. There are several different words for rice in bahasa Indonesia, depending on whether it's growing in the field, uncooked or cooked, or depending on the variety or colour. I have yet to learn them all - but rice growing in fields is "padi" - so calling a field a rice padi is like saying rice rice - don't do that.

Indonesia has 5 official religions, and while for example, the island of Flores is mostly Catholic, and Bali has a mostly Hindu population, Muslims are predominant throughout the country. “My” island, Sulawesi, is largely Muslim. In Jeneponto women choose to wear a jilbab (head covering, called a hijab in Arab countries) or not, but I have yet to see any woman in full burka. Apparently Aceh in the far west is host to a more fundamental kind of Islam. However, uniforms are very common; all government workers wear them; and women do consistently wear jilbabs as part of their uniform. School girls also wear them as part of their school uniforms, but the age at which they start to wear them can vary; 6 or 7 year olds are not always required to cover their heads (this may depend on the school they attend). The local Scout troop uniform includes jilbabs for the female Scouts. About three-quarters of women not in uniform will include a jilbab as part of their dress in this area. Younger women tend not to wear them unless they’re attending a special occasion, and in the larger cities you will see fewer women in jilbabs. 

One week in mid-December had several activities dedicated to “Darma Wanita” loosely translated as “Working Women”.  All the female government employees took part in a march to the main square, and for the special occasion, they all wore new uniforms that looked more like exercise outfits (stretchy & quite close-fitting). Each government department had its own colour & design of uniform (the forestry office ladies wore olive green) & there were many different departments. There must have been at least 400 women participating.



Darma Wanita marchers
(above & right)





The most obvious indication that I’m living in a Muslim town is the many mosques, scattered as thickly as churches in Fredericton. And every small village has at least one or two. Call to prayer can be heard from loudspeakers 5 times a day; at about 3:30 am, 6:30 am, noon, 3:30 pm and 6:30 pm. Don’t set your watch by them, the times can vary by several minutes. If the country’s TV network ever sponsors an “Indonesia’s Next Top Imam” or “So you think you can call to prayer” competition I’m entering my guy’s name. He has a mellow voice, with subtle variations and best of all, I can sleep through the earliest call. Staying overnight in Makassar (the provincial capital & largest city on Sulawesi) was a whole different experience - the closest mosque was very nearby, the imam went on for ages and sounded like he was yelling out his  grocery list. Tough to get back to sleep after that.

RIght now, the music in the air is mating frog calls, which started last night as a result of the fresh rain.

Monday, 3 December 2012

Geographic contrast & an interesting tree



Last week all the volunteers were in Bali for the annual conference. Two others & I took advantage of being on the island & went up to Ubud for the weekend before returning to South Sulawesi. This is a tourist destination about an hour's drive north of Denpasar - apparently some of the movie "Eat, Pray, Love" was filmed here.

















Then, on Tuesday I had to take the 2.5 hour flight to Singapore & back on the same day to renew my temporary work visa - Indonesia requires those on short-term visas to leave the country every 60 days to renew, & VSO hasn't been able to get our year-long visas approved yet. So, Cordelia and I wandered around downtown Singapore for the day.









The white lotus-like building on the left is the ArtScience Museum in Singapore.
















Wednesday it was a flight back to Makassar and a minibus to Jeneponto. Those 3 days certainly emphasized the glaring contrasts in lifestyle all within a relatively small geographic area.













And now, for all the tree people - this (below) is a cannonball tree in a park in Singapore. The flower-bearing branches grow out on the lower trunk. All stages of flower & fruit occur at the same time, year round.
Latin name: Couroupita guianensis
Family: Lecythidaceae



 

Flowers are fragrant, used by adherents to Hinduism for worship. The fruit grows to about 20 cm in diameter, but is not edible. The hard shell is used to make containers & utensils.